SHK Law Files Lawsuit Against Starbucks in High-Profile Burn Case

A South Los Angeles woman’s fight for justice against Starbucks sheds light on the potential dangers lurking within seemingly routine coffee orders. The LA Times reported that the woman, who suffered severe burns, has filed a negligence lawsuit against the company under SHK Law’s representation. This lawsuit raises concerns about safety protocols in fast-food establishments.

The Incident: A Drive-Through Disaster

On August 25, 2022, Muriel Evans visited a Starbucks drive-through in Lynwood, California, for what should have been a routine coffee order. However, the situation quickly turned dangerous during the handoff of the coffee, when the lid of the coffee cup popped off and the barista spilled the coffee onto Evans’ lap. The lawsuit claims that the coffee was served at a scorching 190 degrees Fahrenheit – just shy of boiling point, which could be considered negligent serving practices. The lawsuit further claims that the lid was defective – a well-known issue with Starbucks’ lids, which has caused numerous other burn injuries over the years. The lawsuit seeks punitive damages against Starbucks due to its knowing disregard for the safety of its customers, which includes serving coffee at scalding hot temperatures in cups with defective and unsecure lids.

The Lasting Effects

The consequences of this incident extend far beyond the initial injury. Evans now faces:

• The physical and emotional challenges of living with severe burns
• The potential for lifelong pain and limitations due to nerve damage
• The psychological impact of disfigurement

These injuries underscore the potential dangers of serving extremely hot beverages without proper safety measures in place. The severity of these injuries classifies this as a catastrophic burn injury case, which can lead to long-term damage, scarring, and disfigurement.

The Legal Action

In a tactical collaboration, Brian J. Kim and Maureen Hennessey of SHK Law have aligned with Trial Lawyers 4 Justice to represent Ms. Evans in her case against Starbucks. Nick Rowley, a prominent partner celebrated as one of the country’s most accomplished legal minds, is at the forefront. The lawsuit claims that Starbucks demonstrated:

• Negligence by serving coffee at excessively high temperatures
• Use of defective cup lids prone to dislodging
• Reckless disregard for customer safety despite being aware of the associated risks

The legal action aims to secure compensatory damages for Ms. Evans’ medical expenses while pursuing punitive damages to catalyze industry-wide improvements in safety standards. In seeking punitive damages, the attorneys contend that Starbucks demonstrated gross negligence or a willful disregard for customer safety.

Industry Practices Reach a Boiling Point

Through its investigation of this Starbucks case, SHK Law is uncovering more than a single spilled coffee—it is shedding light on deeper industry practices now facing serious scrutiny. Several critical issues are beginning to emerge:

1. The Goldilocks Zone of Beverage Temperature: How hot is too hot? This case challenges the industry to find the optimal balance between serving a satisfyingly warm coffee and ensuring customer safety.
2. Lid Design Dilemma: Are current to-go cup lids adequate for customer protection? This lawsuit could spur innovation in spill-resistant designs that prioritize consumer safety without compromising convenience.
3. The True Cost of Convenience: Fast food chains emphasize speed, but at what cost? This case may prompt a thorough review of training procedures, quality control, and safety protocols in high-volume, fast-paced environments.

This case has implications that could go well beyond the courtroom. It has the potential to redefine ‘duty of care’ and customer safety standards across the food service industry. At SHK Law, we don’t just win cases—we hold corporations accountable and fight for a safer world.

Justice Starts Here

If you’ve been injured due to corporate negligence, don’t face this painful process alone. At SHK Law, we make your fight our own. With millions won for our clients, we combine tireless dedication, expert collaboration, and an unshakable commitment to justice to achieve the best possible results.

Our trial-ready approach ensures we’re always one step ahead. By preparing to go to trial from day one, we negotiate from a position of strength, often leading to much higher settlements for our clients. Our case results speak for themselves:

• 50+ Combined Years of Experience
• 99% Success Rate
• Over $350 Million Secured for Our Clients
• No Upfront Costs: Free Consultation, Contingency-based Fees

Been Injured? We Can Help.

Not sure if you have a case? Get a free case evaluation—no strings attached. Confidential consultations are available 24/7. Call (818) 960-0011 and take the first step towards justice today.

Don’t Let Your Rights Expire. Get Answers Now.